More Stories:
BreakForNews Homepage

Thur 10pm

mp3 or

Dems Pocket $52 Million,
CNN Ignores Evidence,
and Officials Stonewall...
What Vote Fraud?

by Bev Harris,
in posts on Democratic Underground, 24th Nov 2004

We saw Ukrainian presidential election coverage on CNN last night. It was surreal They were saying that in the Ukraine elections aren't transparent. 'Scuse me?

This, after CNN said they weren't interested in filming 59 orange-tagged records from Volusia, Florida showing that our elections have not been at all transparent, and are missing one-third of the key documents entirely. Psst. Don't look here. Look there.

The screen shots of the NETWORKED (!) Volusia County GEMS server alone, along with the logs showing attempts to access it remotely, should have hit the national press.

According to a statement by the Supervisor of Elections on November 17, 2004, the GEMS computer is not networked, and is "stand alone." The furnished computer logs show evidence of at least two attempts to remotely access the GEMS central tabulator, which is claimed to be secure. A computer screen shot printout on November 17, 2004 (found in the trash) shows that the GEMS computer at that time had two networked hard drives.

I showed the logs to CNN cameramen yesterday, along with 59 orange-tagged poll tapes that were missing signatures, zero tapes, sometimes missing results altogether! No interest in getting a shot of that smoking gun at all.

We intereviewed poll workers. On camera. Showed them the poll tapes we were given by Volusia County. To a person, they said, with great concern, "That is NOT what we submitted to the county."

One remembered the results on his poll tape. What he remembered, before ever seeing the results tape or hearing what was on our copy, was not the same. His memory for a precinct with a tad over 400 voters had 60 more votes for Kerry. Of course, that's not legally binding, since he hadn't written it down.

And don't forget that in Volusia, poll workers were told to bring their memory cards and poll tapes off to 'drop offs' or 'depots', and it was there that the modem-ing occurred. We have no information whatsoever on who was in those depots, or what they were doing, or what equipment was there.

Meahwhile a completely irresponsible Kerry Campaign holds on to a $52 million litigation war chest accumulated from citizen donations for that purpose.

If they were the slightest bit interested in either voting system integrity or actually winning, they would have litigated the Black Box Voting records requests to apply some real muscle into prompt disclosure of audit materials, at least in Ohio and Florida. Failure to comply with sunshine laws is against the law, yet a citizens group like Black Box Voting cannot claim legal urgency, forcing immediate compliance, in the same way that a campaign can. There is no question that if the campaign had enforced the sunshine laws, analyzing the audit data, two things would have happened:

1) records would have been produced
2) auditing would have been enabled, and we all know that would have produced hard evidence of irregularities.

You have to wonder. The purpose of our audits is to get some real answers, so we don't have to wonder any more.

We are a consumer protection group, not a political schmoozing group. We are getting support from many elections officials who are just as concerned as we are. Many officials are very accomodating and their audit diagnostics check out.

Election officials only have to survive 10 days, or, in some places, 20 days. That's all they have to stall. After that, wrong results cannot result in candidates being removed from office unless there is evidence that the candidate himself was involved in the fraud. Of course, there will be insulation of the candidate, as this stuff is performed by operatives, not candidates.

Public records laws are already sufficient, in most cases, but need litigation and injunctions to back them up when public officials don't comply. Stay tuned for actions shortly that will help put an end to stonewalling.

Remember, some of the records we requested were already public on election night -- such as the interim summary results reports and the poll tapes. There is no reason whatsoever to withhold these.

Proving fraud after it is too late to put the wrongs right is just not an option. It is a simple matter to put this right, but it involves getting the audit diagnostics in a timely manner (by the way, it is not just "Bev," but a nationally recognized nonprofit 501c(3) group).

Now, if the head of the League of Women Voters came in and asked for records, are you saying it's just fine not to give them over until it's too late?

Note also, that the lawsuit filed yesterday targets the supervisor of elections position. Think carefully about the implications of this. Patricia Northey was a candidate who had pledged to clean things up, beginning with housecleaning a few employees who have been habitually obstructive. She was favored to win. The candidate who in fact became the new supervisor of elections was hand-picked by the current regime.

It isn't okay to wait until it's too late to put the right candidates in, the ones people actually voted for. That includes local as well as national races. And yes, it is now too late.

The Dems did nothing to help themselves, let me clarify. As a nonpartisan nonprofit 501c(3), we cannot get involved in campaigns, recounts and the like. However, by sending the records request to every county in the nation, and publishing the exact documents needed on the web site by midnight Nov. 2, this put ALL parties on notice what was needed in order to properly audit.

We made ourselves available for consultation on exactly what records to request and how to use them for auditing.

Other political parties have used information from our public records request to set up their own recounts and audits. Citizens groups have also done so on a local basis.

Therefore, the road map for the Kerry campaign was right there. Though we could not accept, and they certainly did not offer, assistence on securing our own request, they certainly should have filed an identical request themselves, litigated and muscled counties into compliance in Ohio and Florida, and it would have been easy for them to get teams of computer people to examine the logs and teams of auditors to match up the records. This all could have been done in a matter of three most, 5 days, with the muscle they had.

Instead, they rebuffed our attempts to provide expertise, advice, or evidence, and they made no effort whatsoever to do any auditing at all, nor even to obtain the records needed for simple, quick, diagnostics.

More recently, we have had overtures, but I admit I've been pretty rude and completely without patience with them. Too late, and far too little emphasis on what really needs to be done.

The Kerry attorney in Volusia, by the way, came by but asked not a single question, never asked to look at any evidence, and told one of the producers of Votergate that he thought Black Box Voting was just here to "stir up trouble."

We were very open about the problems we anticipated with this -- the Election Protection effort, which was admirable, was focused solely on watching the casting of the vote, rather than the counting of the vote. When concerned people with access to decisionmakers tried to bring this huge ommission to the attention of people who could take corrective action, they said they were not interested and, in some cases, refused to even take the phone to talk with Black Box Voting.

After the election, everyone came to us asking what we can do. Many people expected Black Box Voting, an organization held together only by the grit of volunteers and the efforts of three full time investigators and a board of directors, with a shoestring budget, to overturn the national election. Not only was this the expectation unrealistic (though our nonpartisan charter would prohibit us from seeking a recount anyway), but the clock had already been run out.

There's a loophole that we'll need to get corrected in elections law, because it is blocking reasonable efforts to audit, confirm, or litigate elections in the U.S.
In most states, you can't request a recount or contest an election based on statistics. Even in Florida, where statistical evidence is permitted, the use of statistics is iffy in a court challenge. As soon as one expert sets it up, another can be counted upon to knock it down.

Recently, for example, attorney Lowell Finley came to Florida to pursue the option of contesting the Florida election. According to Florida law, contesting the Kerry election in Florida would require evidence that over 380,000 votes would be in doubt. Statistical evidence cited 260,000 votes in question -- but that study, the Berkeley study, is now being refuted by the Irvine study, and likelihood of prevailing in court on back-and-forth statistics is unlikely.

Even if that statistical information had been sufficient to prove 260,000 votes at risk, this would need to be supplemented by another 120,000 votes from other counties in the study. This kind of information could have been available, had counties complied with the Nov. 2 public records request filed by Black Box Voting. Unfortunately, most counties did not comply in a timely manner, and many refused to provide the information at all.

The audit data we obtained in Volusia County is another matter. Here, we have established plenty of evidence sufficient to take an election into contest. Volusia County, by itself, may have put some 30,000 presidential votes in question.

To get evidence comparable to what we have in Volusia County, basic audit diagnostics must be provided by the county in a timely manner. (To view the audit diagnostics we sent to every county in the country on Nov. 2, just after the polls closed, go to and scroll down to an article titled "Are we insane? Voting without auditing?")

Now, here's the problem: All of the largest Florida counties stalled the records request past the filing deadlines. Some did it skillfully, by being out of the office, saying they didn't receive it, saying people were out of town...some did it clumsily, telling us to go jump in the lake.

The bottom line is: Most votes in Florida, and nearly all votes in Ohio, could not be audited because the secretary of state (Ohio) or the key county officials (Florida) would not part with the basic public information needed to launch a proper audit. While we will get the records, we will not get them in a timely manner.

This needs to be changed. Black Box Voting is in the process of setting up voting machine citizen audit protocols, and we plan to launch a major national citizen education effort to show people how to do both diagnostic audits and fraud audits using the public records tools available to all of us.

National elections cannot be compromised very easily without problematic local officials. A true cleanup is going to have to take place county by county, and we will need all of you to do it.

I know we have been slow to put some of our volunteers to work on real auditing. That is because, if you don't know exactly what you're doing, you'll get your butt kicked.

A citizen audit group is now working on Holmes County, Florida, and of course Volusia is in full swing (I'm about to do another post on the lawsuit filed yesterday requesting that the Volusia County election be set aside).

This is a problem that can be solved, but we need more teeth in legislation to require counties to produce audit materials immediately after elections, so that citizens groups can have at least 7 days to analyze the information and follow up on discrepancies and ommissions. Right now, elections officials can stonewall and there are no consequences, if they do it skillfully.

(For those who do it unskillfully, stay tuned. We aren't done with 'em.)

For those of you waiting on Ohio, it is certainly frustrating. Kenneth Blackwell is certainly the 2004 equivalent of Katherine Harris. He has set a state policy of obstructiveness, making it almost impossible to get the kind of information needed to prove the counting was correct.

Doing the auditing correctly, especially in coordination with local citizens groups, can produce fireworks. Volusia County now has its hands full.

We have consistently been ahead of the curve on this. We identified the problems with voting machine reliability and nontransparency way back in 2002; we have stressed since 2003 that the problems are not just touch screens, but with all computerized systems, including optical scans and punch cards, and we have focused on auditing as the solution since mid-2003.

While everyone else was focusing on getting a "paper trail" (without making any efforts to ensure that something meaningful was done to USE the paper to audit), we were focusing on auditing ommissions, both with the machines and with election procedures. While 40,000 people charged off to watch votes being cast, we published guidelines to create human audit logs for the central tabulator, the machine that COUNTS the votes.

In short, the time to set things up to contest this election on a national basis was a few weeks BEFORE the election. No one in a decisionmaking capacity bothered to do that, though we had been publicly calling for this, even going to Washington D.C. in September to meet with people and hold a press conference, in September.

Now, after the fact, people are realizing the mistakes.

1. Focusing on touch-screens and computer solutions, instead of focusing on basic auditing and bookkeeping

2. Focusing on touch screen machines instead of the central tabulator and the optical scans and punch card computers as well.

3. Failing to put any procedures in place to audit elections properly on a county by county basis

And now, failing to use the legal muscle of the party to enforce production of audit documents, and failure to do any auditing at all.

The result is that the American People are left with uncertainty on a nationwide basis.

Thur 10pm

mp3 or

Stay tuned for an upcoming national conference which will be put on by Black Box Voting, called "Help America Audit," in which we will teach citizens groups, political parties, candidates, and private citizens how to conduct citizen audits of elections on a county by county basis, the only method available to us, really.

Stay tuned, also, for an action we'll be taking soon to beef up compliance with the public records requests needed for election auditing.

Bev Harris
Executive Director
Black Box Voting

        Vote Fraud Found in Volusia, Florida BFNews 17 Nov
Also: Vote fraud investigators visit Volusia News-Journal 17 Nov
Also: Group Demands Volusia Vote Tallies News-Journal 18 Nov
Also: Volusia Memos Disclose 2000 Vote Fraud

  Top Stories
Thugs, Racketeers
Count American Votes

A little-known election company called Sequoia Pacific, which put the current U.S. "regime" in power four years ago, is again at the center of controversy... for the second Presidential election in a row.
Internet Abuzz with Election
Conspiracy Theories

More than two weeks after Sen. John Kerry conceded defeat and urged national unity, the Internet is still ablaze with accusations and theories about alleged voting irregularities, rigged equipment, machines that counted backward or stopped counting, and all manner of mishap from incompetence to corruption and outright fraud.

Liberals, the election is over, live with it

Group wants probe into fraud in Duluth and several states
Bush Swing Was
260,000 'Ghost'
Votes in Florida
--from eVoting Machines

A study by Prof Michael Hout and colleagues at Berkeley Univ. says that irregularities associated with electronic voting machines may have swung 260,000 excess votes to George Bush in Florida.

Counties with electronic voting machines were significantly more likely to show increases in support for President Bush between 2000 and 2004 compared to counties with paper ballots.
Conservative Lawyer Backs VoteFraud ! MUST READ

We've Been
by Edgar J. Steele

Houston, we have a problem.

Look -the people apparently disenfranchised this time around primarily are those with whom I generally disagree, but the fundamental unfairness of what has taken place offends me, not to mention the path down which America now treads.

If this is what it means to be conservative today, I want to be liberal .Read
" I think Kerry actually won the election and allowed
Bush to steal it. In retrospect, it appears to me that
Al Gore did the same thing." - Edgar J Steele

" I stole the
election, and
   you can't
prove it !
--Karl Rove

Wanna bet?  VoteFraud Page

     by Kathy McMahon
   Fri 26 Nov

Kerry clings to hopes
of recount victory

"Every vote will be counted, and we Democrats aren't afraid to fight to protect voters' rights," said Kerry spokesman David Wade on Tuesday. A Kerry victory in Ohio would be enough to seize the White House.

In another signal a note was posted on the campaign website yesterday that called on supporters to contribute to the Kerry-Edwards 2004 General Election Legal and Accounting Compliance Fund.

Jessee Jackson to call for election investigation

Did Dubbya rig the election?

Exit Polls Still a Puzzle

Rights group sues in Florida over election results

U.S. Election commission: Voting problems widespread

Top PACs Favored GOP Candidates by 10-1 margin

Bush 'victory" beat odds
of 4.5 BILLION to ONE

Kerry’s Kingmaker Play

Big Media's Democracy Double Standards

American Fascism

New Ohio voter tales feed floodtide of doubt about Repub election manipulation

Updated: Unexplained
Exit Poll Discrepancy: Part I

TV is our Enemy

2004 A Left Gatekeeper
Republican Conspiracy!

VoteFraud DisInfo Alerts:

Masden's BS Rumor

The CyberNet Distraction

NY Times Hypocrisy

Wash Post Lip Service

Bev Harris Vs Disinfo

Florida Officials Using Delaying Tactics to Block Recount Moves

Florida Lawsuit Cites
Evidence of Attempts
to Hack Vote Tabulator

Be a Fighting Democrat

FBI Agents Raid Dems

Bev Harris on CNN

Incredible Coincidences?

Zogby Vs. Mitofsky  Also

VoteFraud Moonshine

Kerry Campaign Slick PR?

GAO To Investigate
USA 2004 Election

VoteFraud Activists
Sue Volusia County

US Urges Ukraine Not to Release Election Results
"The United States is deeply disturbed by extensive and credible indications of fraud committed in the Ukrainian presidential election"

No Ohio Recount Until
Dec. 6th says Judge

Scoop: American Coup II

Get Ready for the Spin

Kerry defeat spawns
thoughts of conspiracy

Republican Slams
Election over Exit Polls

Cleveland OH
data weirdness

Cuyahoga ballots invalid

Whole World Is Watching!

Prof. Steven Freeman
Exit Poll Update

Widespread Election
Fraud in Cleveland?

Dean for DNC Chair?

The Ohio Recount

Hack The Vote FAQ

Year Democracy Ended

Privatizing, Monopolizing, & Politicizing Voting --The List

No Keith,
here's the reality:

If Blackwell delays the recount past Dec. 13, no argument will persuade one single Republican to risk his life by voting against Bush.

VoteFraud: You may
remove your tinfoil hat

How the Ohio election
was rigged for Bush

Recount Ohio? Go Look

We got Watergate here

Saving Your Right to Vote

Massaging the
Inconsistent Exit Polls

Democracy in Question
"Something is definitely wrong," -- John Zogby, of polling firm Zogby Intl.

Give no quarter to voter
fraud and suppression

"The catcalls are meant
to divert the people from pursuing electoral justice."

2004 Exit Poll "Red Shift"

Vote Watch 2004

2004 Election Theft

An Evidence Log of
Possible Election Fraud


Let’s Get Real
How better to commit the perfect crime than to insist it never happened? This rip-off was as flagrant as the L.A. cops’ assault on Rodney King, and yet is dismissed as delusion.

Could one hacker
alter an entire election?

How to Hack the Vote:
the Short Version

Computers Threw
the Vote to Bush

Stolen election of 2004: Welcome back to Hell

Exit versus Final Results

'Stinking Evidence'
of Vote Fraud in Florida

Is in denial?

Blackout on Berkeley

Bev Harris wants
Volusia vote tallies

More Indiana Counties
Report E-Vote Errors

Ohio Democrats ignore
Kerry Concession to
begin fight over ballots

Just In: Bush 200k+
extra votes in Florida?

Just In: Olberman

Iraqis to boycott
'fake' elections

Bev Harris group demands Volusia vote tallies

Ohio Democrats ignore
Kerry Concession to
begin fight over ballots

Stolen Election Update

More Indiana Counties
Report E-Vote Errors

Was It Hacked?

Oh Brother, Ohio,
and O'Reilly
by Keith Olberman

Kerry Inches Closer
in Ohio
by D. Shuster

Kerry Hedges Bets?
See Also Transcript

Diebold Staff Ran NC
Systems on Election Day

Bill Lockyer OUR Friend?

Media Censor VoteFraud?
Boston Globe

Ohio recount: From
Conspiracy to Reality

Ohio Dems in on the Fix?

Lawsuit In Broward

Ohio recount: From
Conspiracy to Reality

$100,000 Reward for Finding the Ohio Fraud

VoteFraud's Mr. Big
in Smoking Gun Find

Kerry Lawyer: I was
an accessory to fraud.

Dems in on conspiracy?

USA Tired of Democracy?

Can't fool computer geeks

Voting Problems Hit Media

NYC Indymedia Censors

Yahoo VoteFraud Forum   

Bush Threatens to Nuke
America if VoteFraud
is Challenged

Millions of Americans
Think Kerry Won

Democrats win in court

250 Milion to One
Bush's Victory Odds

Kerry Won Ohio Palast

NC Election:
Clear Case for Fraud

Two N.C. Races Held
Up by Voting Problems

Dear GW, by Bob Jones

Rumors of irregularities
fuel debate on election

Mainstream Whitewash

Democrats Sue Over Ballots
in Wash. Governor Race

5 Things You Can
Do Right Now to
Reclaim Democracy

by Bev Harris

Bush's 'Incredible'
Vote Tallies

MSNBC's Olbermann :
Did Your Vote Count?

Media Black Out on
Vote Fraud Allegations

No Blackout - says Media

Computer glitch
still baffles county clerk

Countinghouse Blues
--Too many votes


Fla slot machines issue
--Absentees 9-1 in favor

More votes than voters

Kerry Margins: Paper
and Non-paper ballot

The Speech Which
Kerry Never Gave

November 2 :
Exit Poll Scam

Kerry Margins: Paper-ballot and Non-paper ballot states

Bush's 8 Mil New Votes?

Florida Slot Machines Absentee votes went
9-to-1 in favor

Absentee ballots expected
to tip scales against gambling

Machine error caused
slots vote problem

Florida hit by "Perfect storm" for gambling interests

Slots win in late surge

Fighting the slots Goliath

Jeb Bush opposes slots

Never Say Die-bold

John Kerry lied

Why Kerry Conceded

Democratic Party Blog :
Florida rigged scanners

"Now comes
the Revolution"

Vote Hacked:
Evidence Mounts

House Dems Seek
Election Inquiry

PR Gesture Only

Was Ohio Honest and Fair?
Nothing about other States

Hello: You are now
living in a fascist empire

Pushing the 'Peak Oil' Con

The Stolen Election
More Peak Oil propaganda

TruVote's fate may be
clearer by Election Day 04

TruVote sitting on
sideline for election

Two companies count
80% of U.S. election

Nader's N.H. election
recount bid is invalid

OSCE Election Observers
are another NWO facade

Massive Voter Suppression and Corruption in Ohio

  More Stories...


More Stories:
BreakForNews Homepage

                                                          Home                   Last 5 Days   NewsBytes   Archive   Links  
Original Content Copyright © 2004